There’s one thing that I take almost as seriously as my writing, and that’s my critiquing. For those of you not familiar with this aspect of the Kid Lit world, I’ll fill you in because it’s a curious but necessary process. You can pay people to critique your manuscript, join critique groups, and/or establish critique partnerships. It’s a swapping of stories, suggestions, and constructive criticism, from people across the industry. Think of it as “you scratch my back, I’ll scratch yours” but instead it’s “You read mine, provide feedback, I’ll gladly do the same.” Many published authors provide critiquing services for a fee since they have the industry insight and personal success to stand on, but there are countless free opportunities as well. I’ve talked about it before, I have a group, a few partnerships and some experience with paid services.
I enjoy critiquing, and as I said, I take it seriously. If it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a posse to publish a book. I try hard not to use empty words, keeping my comments productive and never shy away from the hard/awkward/clumsy/obvious questions. I approach every critique as a way to help another writer, and I’m hopeful that those who look at my work for me do the same. It’s all about karma, folks. I want to be an active and engaged member of this community. I want to contribute in a way that helps me to find success but also helps others on their way to publication. I want to be known as a good and effective critique partner.
Every chance I can, I learn something about writing, and the same is true for my critiques. I make notes and follow a similar set of questions/prompts. I always give it more than one look, and usually ‘put a sleep cycle on it.’ Do you know what I don’t do? I don’t do a very good job when it comes to critiquing myself. This glaring truth surfaced this week, as I was getting ‘final’ thoughts from a couple of different partners, and they each sent stories my way. I thought about the WIP that I’m readying for a contest, and realized that if I looked at my own work, I would have comments for days! What’s the deal? Why is there a disconnect in my brain? How is it that I can hold others to higher standards but my own story slips by with major structural/formatting issues? Thankfully this came to light in time to shine the light on my own work. I took my critiquing process and turned the tables, forcing myself to look at my WIP as someone else would. To make a long story short, it was a roller coaster and my self-esteem took a hit. Thankfully, I’m resilient and I was able to work through it. I think, and hope, that I elevated my story to a new, and necessary level. As soon as I hit ‘publish’, I’m sending in my contest entry. He’s as ready as he’ll ever be. Wish me luck!
Thanks for reading, come back anytime!